ON REPENTANCE AND GLASS HOUSES: A RESPONSE TO CHARLOTTESVILLE

Activism

Glasshouse-philip-johnson.jpg

About 26 years ago Nicki and I were just married and living in Nashville, Tennessee.  We experienced a sermon one Sunday that has meaningfully impacted the way we test our reactions to infuriating situations.  The pastor talked about the ways in which we are most angered by qualities in others that we least like in ourselves.  He talked about “combing our own hair in the mirror” of others. 

The events that took place in Charlottesville through the various responses by President Trump have made me deeply sad and angry.  Utilizing the well worn lesson from our Nashville pastor I have recognized that a significant contributor to my pain is the reflection of myself and my own insensitive and ignorant comments and responses to various events, perspectives and arguments. 

Although I would never have self-identified as a white supremacist, as a white Christian male I have enjoyed the supremacy granted me through my unearned privilege.  Most egregiously, I have often allowed myself the delusion that I earned my privilege.  Although I have spent time focused on neutralizing some of the ways my privilege works, there are many more areas that I continue to protect.

When I hear others say horrible and hurtful things about racial, religious, ethnic, sexual or gender identity differences I am reminded of the ways that I think, express or believe no less ignorant concepts through the filtering lens of a well-educated, high EQ, progressive.

So while I unequivocally condemn the beliefs, speech and actions of white supremacists, neo-Nazis and similar groups and similarly disagree with President Trump that the history of slavery is reasonably remembered through the unqualified honoring of leaders of the Confederacy; I also believe that my 62-year complicity with the advantages afforded me through the fortunes of my birth are in equivalent need for repentance.

I pray that at United we not only teach students to express rage at the injustices committed by others but to work to dismantle the injustices in which they and we consciously and unconsciously participate.

Many of us have chuckled at the out of touch nature of the quote frequently attributed to Marie Antoinette about the poor eating cake when they could not afford bread.  We all express some of that out of touch quality when we are judgmental about those experiencing homelessness, individuals with mental illness who act awkwardly, immigrants who struggle with English, people who are not able to write well or the myriad of those less protected by the traditional umbrella of a progressive theological and political perspective. President Trump is masterful at insensitive comments and there is no place for that in government leadership.  It would give some positive purpose to these difficult times if we used them to take stock of our individual glass houses.

Explore More Articles

Lauren Busey (’07) Ministers to a New Beloved Community at Pickledilly Skokie

  Lauren Busey (’07) grew up in the Lutheran church,  earned an undergraduate degree from Luther College, and thought she would probably attend a Lutheran seminary. Then, at a Luther College women’s retreat, Rev. Dr. Christie Cozad Nueger (’80)— Professor Emerita of Pastoral Counseling and Pastoral Theology (1992–2005)—was the featured speaker and knew Lauren’s campus pastor. “So,” Lauren remembers, “we just kind of got to talking, and within a couple of weeks, I was enrolled at United.”  United “was a good fit,” Lauren asserts. She found a welcoming community of fellow students and treasured professors. Those who had the greatest impact include Rev. Dr. Jann Cather Weaver (Associate Professor Emerita of Worship, and Theology and the Arts, 2001–2012), Dr. Marilyn Salmon† (Professor Emerita of New Testament Theology, 1989–2014), and Dr. Carolyn Pressler (Professor Emerita of Biblical Interpretation, 1990–2020).  (more…)

Images of Hope: Advent in Art

Art has the tremendous power to restore us in a time when our world seems to make no sense and we need a moment of respite and encouragement from our daily struggles. A single photograph of a flower or a laughing child can buoy our spirit to carry on. (more…)

Alex Sánchez Rodriguez Finds Vocational Inspiration at United

  Alex Sánchez Rodriguez, who plans to graduate from United in 2026 with an MA in Religion and Theology, was initially drawn to the seminary’s Interreligious Chaplaincy program. Since taking more classes, engaging with his professors, becoming involved in the Student Leadership Collective, and taking on other extracurricular activities, he has settled on a new calling. “I discovered,” Alex shares, “that I have a natural affinity toward academics.” In fact, he admits, “I want to be like my professors.” Before coming to United, Alex was a substitute teacher in Puerto Rico. Since he moved to Minnesota, he has been working in student development and promoting student success. The priority of student success is the throughline, Alex perceives, from his current role and an academic career. “If I am to go into academia,” he explains, “part of my success as a teacher, professor, and researcher depends on the success of my future students.”  (more…)